1939
| Name | Position | College |
|---|---|---|
| I.B. Hale | T | TCU |
| Charley Holm | B | Alabama |
| Dick Todd | B | Texas A&M |
| Dave Anderson | B | California |
| Quinton Lumpkin | C | Georgia |
| Bo Russell | T | Auburn |
| Wilbur Moore | B | Minnesota |
| Jimmy Johnson | B | Washington |
| Jim German | B | Centre |
| Bob O'mara | B | Duke |
| Steve Silvinski | G | Washington |
| Bob Hoffman | B | USC |
| Eric Tipton | B | Duke |
| Dick Farman | T | Washington St. |
| Clyde Shugart | T | Iowa St. |
| Boyd Morgan | B | USC |
| Phil Smith | T | St. Benedict |
| Paul Coop | T | Centre |
| Matt Kuber | G | Villanova |
| Al Cruver | B | Washington |
1938
| Name | Position | College |
|---|---|---|
| Andy Farkas | B | Detroit |
| Sam Chapman | B | California |
| Dave Price | C | Mississippi |
| Elmer Dohrmann | E | Nebraska |
| Roy Young | T | Texas A&M |
| Bill Hartman | B | Georgia |
| Ed Parks | C | Oklahoma |
| Jack Abbitt | B | Elon |
| Dick Johnson | E | Washington |
| Henry Bartos | G | North Carolina |
1937
| Name | Position | College |
|---|---|---|
| Sammy Baugh | B | TCU |
| Nello Falaschi | B | Santa Clara |
| Maurice Elder | B | Kansas St. |
| Dick Bassi | G | Santa Clara |
| Chuck Bond | T | Washington |
| Jimmie Cain | B | Washington |
| Rotta Holland | G | Kansas St. |
| Joel Eaves | E | Auburn |
| Bill Docherty | T | Temple |
| Dom Mac Cara | E | N.C. St. |
1936
| Name | Position | College |
|---|---|---|
| Riley Smith, | B | Alabama |
| Keith Topping | E | Stanford |
| Ed Smith | B | NYU |
| Paul Tangora | G | Northwestern |
| Wilson Groseclose | T | TCU |
| Terry Lutz | T | California |
| Don Irwin | B | Colgate |
| Wayne Millner | E | Notre Dame |
| Marcel Saunders | G | Loyola (Ca.) |
